Tribunal Suprême opens door to overturn €209m Caroli ruling
By Zak Jackson, MonacoViews Editorial
Monaco's Tribunal Suprême has accepted it could annul a definitive award in the Esplanade des Pêcheurs case, but only if fraud is proven.
The Tribunal Suprême has made an unprecedented ruling this week in the long-running dispute over the Esplanade des Pêcheurs development. Judges have accepted the principle that even a definitive sentence, one that would normally be beyond appeal, could in theory be revoked if fraud is established.
The case centres on 209 million euros the Principality owes to Groupe Caroli following the collapse of the Esplanade des Pêcheurs project, a waterfront scheme near Monaco's fishing harbour that never came to fruition. The princely government has argued that fraud lay behind the original award and is seeking to use this as grounds to avoid paying out the sum in full.
This week's decision does not settle the matter. The court has opened the door to revocation in principle, but the government must still demonstrate that fraud actually occurred before any of the 209 million euros can be clawed back. For residents and businesses watching Monaco's public finances, the case remains unresolved, with the next stage likely to turn on evidence rather than legal principle.